Right now there must be a million How-Kurt-Vonnegut-Changed-My-Life-When-I-First-Read-Him-As-A-Teenager stories clogging the intertubes, so I'll spare you mine. I will say I was sufficiently entranced and haunted by Slaughterhouse-Five that I successfully begged to be allowed to see the necessarily-at-least-R-rated movie adaptation of the book that came out in 1972, when I was twelve. I had believed that Alain Resnais was the only guy who could handle the book's "unstuck in time" structure; in so doing, I seriously underrated the very deft George Roy Hill (not to mention screenwriter Stephen Geller, who won a special prize at Cannes for his adaptation; Hill won a Jury prize there as well). I was moved and dazzled by the movie, and a not-overly-precocious portion of my preteen self was very happy with Valerie Perrine's depiction of Montana Wildhack.
Slaughterhouse-Five was the second movie adaptation of a Vonnegut work (the first being a misbegotten version of his play Happy Birthday Wanda June in 1971, starring Rod Steiger and directed by Mark Robson.) It remains, I think, the best, although two first-rate pics come in behind it—not many, I know, but more than I initially remembered. There's Jonathan Demme's inspired 1982 American Playhouse mini-feature Who Am I This Time?, starring Christopher Walken, and Keith Gordon's ambitious, gutsy 1996 Mother Night, with Nick Nolte.
I know that the worst Vonnegut adaptation is Alan Rudolph's 1999 Breakfast of Champions, the most blatant betrayal of a literary work since Hollywood's upending of Bernard Malamud's The Natural back in 1984. And at least The Natural presented lots of pretty pictures and nice music before totally inverting Malamud's vision. Breakfast forces you to suffer throughout, and then completely pisses on Vonnegut's conclusion. Vonnegut has a cameo in the picture, which suggests an approval of sorts, but you know, a lot can happen between a set and an editing room. (Rudolph mentor Robert Altman wanted to make a film of Breakfast in the mid-'70s, and cast Sterling Hayden as Kilgore Trout.) I say I know it's the worst without ever having seen 1982's Jerry-Lewis-starring Slapstick (of Another Kind), which is reputed to be monumentally awful. Which it may well be. (Any commentors out there seen it? Fire away!) I insist it cannot be as bad as Breakfast is bad in the way that Breakfast is bad.
Vonnegut's most well-known film cameo is as himself in 1986's Back to School—rich old undergrad Rodney Dangerfield hires him to explain Slaughterhouse-Five. It was on that set that Gordon, who plays Dangerfield's son in the picture, first approached Vonnegut about adapting Mother Night.
I know I shouldn't say this, but I'm both horrified and impressed that Vonnegut remained a smoker to the end. When I saw him speak at William Paterson College way back in the day, I noticed he was a Pall Mall man, too. You ever smoke a Pall Mall? I'm getting a heart attack just thinking about it.
Recent Comments